Anoushka Shankar · Breathing Under Water

Easy

2 min readLast updated November 2026
Table of contents

Dynamics

  • Score mostly p, 1 bar mp
  • Natural volume changes as texture changes
  • Layering (voice + instruments) gives perceived dynamic shifts

Rhythm / Tempo / Meter

  • 84bpm - relaxed, laid-back
  • 4/4: 1 bar of 3/4 - (elongates beat)
  • Sitar rhythmically complex : demi/semiquavers, triplets, quintuplets, septuplets
  • Guitar: ostinato pattern
  • Pad: held like a drone
  • Piano: syncopated
  • Drums: semiquaver pattern enters bar 21
  • manjira + shaker creates syncopation against drums

Texture

  • Bar 1: monophonic (double anacrusis / upbeat)
  • Melody-dominated homophony with polyphonic elements
  • Accompaniment occasionally becomes melodic material
  • Ostinato layers → guitar + piano
  • Dialogue: Voice & sitar intertwine → strongest fusion moment

Structure

  • AABA + Coda:
    • Instrumental introduction
    • A: Verse 1
    • A: Verse 2
    • B: Instrumental bridge / middle 8
    • A: Verse 3
    • Coda

Melody

  • Contrast between ornamented sitar line and less complex line
  • Voice (Nora Jones):
    • Based on pentatonic scale - jazz/soul/R&B style
    • Short phrases, repetitive, largely conjunct, limited range
    • Melismatic
    • Long held notes → suspended notes - unresolved, floaty feeling
    • Coda: repeated leaps of 4ths, bar 44 → octave leap
  • Sitar
    • Improvised
    • Transposed Mixolydian mode, equivalent to Rag Khamaj (Raga)
    • Sitar opening uses a 4 bar melody, repeated with slight variations, working downwards from the C flat to an octave below
    • Ornamentation (alankarna) and Techniques
      • Pitch Bends
      • Microtones
      • Glissando (meend)
  • Contrast: Voice vs sitar


Instrumentation

  • Sitar
  • Warm pad
  • Synth bass
  • Guitar
  • Voice → Nora Jones, overdubbed backing vocals
  • Manjira
  • Programmed synth drums
  • Shaker

Tonality

  • Technically G♭ major (Edexcel)
  • Likely D♭ Mixolydian (ragkhamaj) → modal sound
  • Sounds more modal than strictly major/minor

Harmony

  • Western style chords used in a non-functional way
  • Modal harmony
  • Based on 3 chords
    • G♭sus2/B♭ → C♭sus2 → D♭sus4
    • Every chord uses the D flat and G flat note (Acts like a drone)
  • Slash chord / inversions
  • Chords often inverted → strong stepwise movement, forward momentum
  • Ends on D♭ chord → unresolved or interpreted as D♭ Mixolydian
  • Tonic pedal / drone throughout


Key Revision Points

  • Relaxed Soul/R&B → easy, flowing vibe
  • Melody: short, repetitive, suspended, floaty
  • Fusion highlight = voice + sitar interplay
  • Texture + rhythm + harmony → modal, warm, flowing

Sus chords: ambiguous (not major/minor), add warmth